Creepy Caffeine

EP97 - 10 Mysterious Disappearances with Bizarre Clues Left Behind

August 3, 2020

This week, Whitney and Dani wanted to highlight some strange disappearances that do not have a lot of detail but pack a punch with the bizarre clues left behind. From the cases of Tara Calico, Asha Degree, Timmothy Pitzen... and more. Buckle up because these will leave you with more questions than answers. 


Sources Used This Episode:
10 Mysterious Disappearances with Bizarre Clues -

Top 10 Extremely Unsettling Disappearances -


Things to Check Out This Week:
Breaking Bad (Netflix)
Vanished: The Tara Calico Investigation (Podcast) -
If you’re interested in sharing your creepy stories, email us at
Want to check out our socials? Our merch and bookstore? Maybe buy yourself some coffee using our referral link? Check out our Linktree for all of our links!


To reach us by snail mail:
Creepy Caffeine 
PO Box 12665
Oklahoma City, OK 73157

Play this podcast on Podbean App