Creepy Caffeine

EP34 - Jeff the Killer

May 12, 2019

On this week's episode we discuss how yet another viral CreepyPasta story, Jeff the Killer, spawned a real life case of true crime involving fourteen-year-old Donovan Nicholas.

To read the original CreepyPasta by Sesseur:


Don't forget to subscribe and join us each Sunday!

If you’re interested in sharing your creepy stories, email us at
For more about us and links to all our social media, visit our podcast page at
To reach us by snail mail:
Creepy Caffeine
PO Box 12665
Oklahoma City, OK 73157 

This Week's Recommendations:

Hold Me Closer, Necromancer by Lish McBride


Ectogasm Shop (Pins, Patches, Stickers, Art)


To download a free audiobook today, go to


Play this podcast on Podbean App